Hot Dog
by Doug Salati
New York: Knopf Books for Young Readers, 2022.
Suggested Grade and Interest Level: Preschool through 3
Awards and Reviews: 2023 Caldecott Medal, Washington Post, Publishers Weekly, Kirk’s Reviews: “One of the Best Books of the Year”
Other Languages: Spanish, Canícula
Topics: Cities, Dogs; Emotions and feelings; Perspective-taking; Sea and seashore; Summer season
Skills to Build:
Concepts of print
Vocabulary (Homonyms, Idioms, Prepositions)
Morphological units
Grammar and syntax: Two-and-three-word utterances; Negative structures, Present progressive tense structures, Past tense structures, Advanced syntactic structures
Language literacy (a.k.a. Language discourse): Predicting events, Sequencing events; Cause-and-effect relationships, Problem solving, Storytelling, Drawing inferences, Relating personal experiences, Verbal expression
Articulation of /h/, /s/, and /z/
Fluency
Voice
Executive Functioning (planning and sequencing steps)
Summary: The award-winning story, told with choice few words in rhythmic phrases, captures the essence of the all too familiar conditions of summer in the city, when sweltering streets become too much, even for a city dog,
A dachshund, tethered to its lady owner by its leash, must endure all the commotion of a big city on a hot summer day. This includes energetic young skateboarders, cars skidding into crosswalks, noisy construction zones, and fluttering pigeons alighting everywhere on the sidewalk. It’s easy to see how a little dog could get exasperated.
Events turn 180 degrees (perhaps literally) when its owner takes it on a trip to the seashore. No leash for the little dog means it can discover many pleasures on its own – in the cool breeze. The little dog now runs in and out of the waves, rolls over in the sand, tunnels into the sand, and barks at a big sea lion. When the sun begins to set and the shadows grow long across the shore, it’s time to take down the beach umbrella and head for home – then fall asleep with pleasant dreams of the encounters of the day.
Before the read-aloud, present the cover with the happy little dog at the seashore. You might begin your book talk with the feeling state of the little dog as it is depicted on the cover. Then connect it to the setting. For example, you might ask,
- Where is the dog?
- What might be some reasons it looks so happy?
- What kind of a day is it?”
Concepts of Print
To work on young children’s understanding of print knowledge, point out the letters in the title of the book. Each letter in HOT DOG is capitalized, making it easier to identify the features of the alphabet letter.
Run your finger beneath the title words to show in which direction they are read as you say them aloud.
Then name each letter. Or see if the child recognizes a letter. Ask which letter is repeated in both words. Once the letter O is identified, outline the letter with your finger in both places as you say each word aloud, showing how the O makes the same sound in both words.
Cause-and-effect relationships
While still showing the book’s cover, work on encouraging explanations and connecting causal relationships as you ask thoughtful questions that can lead to predictions. For example –
- What is (or might be) fun about being at the beach?
- How do we know it’s a breezy day?
- What might the dog have in its mouth?
Help children express their responses by scaffolding and elaborating with words such as because, since, and so that to encourage the expression with causal relationships. For example,
- The dog has a shell [in its mouth] because it’s been playing on the beach.
Homonyms, Idioms
Have fun playing with the words hot dog by talking about the various meanings.
- What is the meaning is as it pertains to the picture?
One meaning is the description of a little dog on a summer day, as in a hot dog.
Another meaning is the colloquial name for the dachshund breed, called a hot dog. They are also called sausage dog and wiener dog.
Another meaning for hot dog is a frankfurter in a bun, usually with mustard and relish on top. Something you may like to have at a ballgame or picnic is a hot dog.
Propose another meaning. An expression some people use when they’re excited about something is to exclaim, “Hotdog!” It means something like, “Oh, boy!”
The meaning of the words changes yet again if you are at the beach watching a surfer perform a flamboyant stunt, hotdogging on a surfboard. Now it is an idiom. The meaning cannot be determined by its constituent words. It’s an expression that means showing off.
Homonyms depend on the context in which they are used. They’re good to point out as many jokes are based on multiple meaning words.
During the read-aloud, pause for talk about the events taking shape. The text is sparse, with good essential words. As you share talk about what’s happening on the pages while the dog is in the city, take the opportunity to fill in with book talk that targets specific skills.
Drawing inferences; Relating personal experiences
Turn to the inside title page and see the dog in another setting.
- How has the setting changed?
Describe the dog now, with its hind legs on the bed covers and its front paws on the windowsill. Invite an explanation, such as –
- I wonder why the dog is standing in front of the window.
- What is usually going on when a dog stands in front of a window?
- Is the dog anticipating something? Longing for someone?
Point out or explain the old-style air conditioner in the window.
- What could that mean?
- Why might the dog have its tongue out?
Invite children to share personal experiences about a family dog that may be similar.
Grammar and syntax
Use the action in the illustrations to structure grammar and syntax with good action words in picture descriptions.
To encourage two- and three-word utterances, pause to point out details in the illustrations, then repeat the words of the text for the child to repeat with you, as in –
“Too close!
Too hot!
Too much!”
Then add an additional word or two for the child to repeat. For example,
- It’s too close!
- It’s too hot!
- It’s too much!
Now try extending the utterances by connecting those words with the what, as in
- The people are too close!
- The noise is too loud!
- It’s too much for the dog!
As you pause to describe the little dog on the hot city streets, interpret the dog’s expressions and body language.
Encourage the expression of negative syntactic structures by discussing how the dog feels and what the dog does not like. For instance,
The little dog….
- does not like the steamy sidewalks.
- does not like being too hot.
- does not like being too close.
- does not like all the traffic.
- does not like the loud noise.
The little dog….
- will not move.
- will not budge.
- will not cross the street.
To work on present tense structures, encourage repetition of the text, such as
“Sun sinks down
Moon rises”
Work on present progressive tense with descriptions of the action taking place in the city, such as –
- cars honking,
- people walking
- lady tugging (on the dog’s leash)
- pigeons fluttering (to the sidewalk)
- kid is skateboarding
- dog is refusing (to budge)
- train is moving, rolling (down the track)
especially at the wordless pages that show the dog arriving at the beach. The dog enjoys doing lots of activities. For example,
The little dog is _____
- running on the beach.
- digging in the sand.
- running in the waves.
- shaking off the sand.
- running with the ball.
- barking at a sea lion.
The wordless Illustrations are also ideal for working on advanced sentence structures. Use the passage of time in the story and begin with a carrier phrase for the children to repeat and fill in, such as –
- When the dog is unleashed, _______.
- When the dog hits the sand, _______.
- Once the dog is set free, __________.
- As the dog runs across the beach, _________
When the lady and her dog return home from the beach and settle back into their apartment, use the same concept to continue creating complex sentence structures. For example,
- On their way home they – (i.e., cross the street in the crosswalk, stop at an open market, buy a big pretzel, and so on.)
- When they get back home, they – (i.e., climb the stairs of their apartment building, eat dinner, go to bed, and so on.)
- After their long day, they – (i.e., go to bed, go to sleep, dream about the ocean, and so on.)
Prepositions
The wordless pages also offer an opportunity to support the use of prepositions to describe the direction of the action. For example,
The little dog is running….
- across the sand
- around in circles
- beneath the umbrella
- along the shore
- beside the waves
- away from the waves
- inside the waves
- after a sea lion.
- from a sea lion.
More suggestions:
- The little dog is turning upside down.
- The little dog is shaking off the sand.
More Grammar and syntax
Next, connect the descriptions with feeling states to expand sentences in supporting more advanced syntactic structures. For example, pause at the wordless page showing the little dog encountering a big sea lion for the first time. Use various verbs that connect with the dog’s feeling states. For example,
The little dog ______
- approaches it because he’s curious,
- barks at the big blob when the dog doesn’t know what it is; when he feels confident.
- jumps, gasps when he is surprised [shocked] that it’s a big creature.
- turns around, runs away when he’s scared,
and so on.
More Drawing inferences
When the little dog nearly gets trampled on by the skateboarder, then crosses the busy city amidst the proceeding pedestrians and oncoming car, the text states –
THAT’S IT!
Help children infer meaning from the expression on the little dog’s face and the words of the text. Look at its tongue hanging sideways out of its mouth and its head down, pulling against the leash. Ask questions such as –
- How do you think the dog feels?
- What makes you think so?
Predicting events
Encourage predictions. The book offers great places to pause for this type of reflection. For example, when the illustration shows the little dog in the middle of the crosswalk ahead of the oncoming skateboarder, and the text that reads,
…too much!
encourage the child to make a prediction about the consequences of this by asking –
- “What might happen next?”
Turn the page to see the little dog refusing to budge in the crosswalk, with an oncoming car appearing closer. Were the predictions accurate? Ask the children if they’ve experienced their own dog getting frustrated. Is this understandable? Encourage descriptions of the scene.
On the next page turn, see the lady kneeling, head-to-head with her little dog in the crosswalk, causing a traffic jam as the cars and trucks honk at them to get out of the way.
- Were their predictions correct?
- Did the little dog refuse to budge?
- Is this how dogs behave sometimes?
Morphological units
After our two characters race through the train station to board the train, we see them on their journey to the seaside. The text describes their sights and sensations with the words –
unfolding sky, a salty breeze
Pause to reflect on the meaning of an unfolding sky.
- What was the sky like in the city?
- Could you see a blue sky through all the city’s haze and smog?
- What does the sky look like now?
- Is green slowly fading to blue as the train moves forward?
- Why is unfolding a good word to use for a sky that turns blue as they continue to travel onward?
- What does it mean to fold?
- When something is folded, like a piece of paper, can we see it?
- When we add –un to fold, what does it mean then?
- Can we see it then?
Next, show how to apply the prefix -un to other words. Here are a few words with prefix -un that you can apply to the story:
- un – real
- un – pleasant
- un – comfortable
- un – relenting
- un – wanted
- un – doing
- un – ending
Can you think of more?
Later in the story, when the little dog arrives at the beach, see another opportunity when the lady unleashes the little dog to run and play in the cool breeze. Encourage and support descriptions of the scene that include the word un – leashed.
Articulation
To work on production of /s/ and /z/, simply enjoy all the opportunities provided as you pause to elicit phoneme production at the child’s ability level. The text is heavily loaded with /s/ from the very start. For example, the first page reads:
City
Summer
Steamy
Sidewalks.
There are opportunities on nearly every page and more target words to be found in the illustrations. Whether the child is repeating the words of the text or describing the action on the pages, there is plenty to work with!
More words from the text:
- For /s/: close, scents, so (hot), sit, sniff, that’s taxi, speed, sky, salty, sun, sinks, swallowed, sea, skyline, someplace, supper, and sleep.
- Additional /s/ words found in the illustrations: street, mixing, cement, congestion, sounds, skateboard, crosswalk, pretzel, sun, bicycle, subway, station, seal, sand, listening (with earphones), and sleeping.
- For /z/: crowds, breeze, trains, cools, and rises.
- Additional /z/ words found in the illustrations: busy, pretzels; pigeons, waves, and dreams.
Fluency
Use of the word hot to described both the dog’s feeling state as well as its dachshund breed (shaped like a little hot dog) are great opportunities to work on the fluency technique of steady airflow.
When introducing the book, and in the first part of the story when the little dog is so hot in the summer heat, take the opportunity to describe its feeling state. As you do so, demonstrate phonation of on a steady stream of air as you say hot.
Ask the child to speak the word in the same way, as air blows out prior to phonation.
Then add progressively more words to the utterance, as in
- hot dog
- hot dog in the city
and so on.
Use the short, rhythmic text for working on other fluency techniques, such as easy starts, ease outs, rhythm, and rate.
Use the wordless pages for creating spontaneous utterances using the learned fluency techniques.
Voice
As stated above, the phoneme /h/ is ideal for working on various vocal techniques, such as pitch, clarity, and even loudness.
Use the initial sound of hot to produce optimum vocal placement and sustain optimum pitch and loudness levels. Use the pages of short text and those without text to extend utterances and maintaining good vocal techniques, as in,
- Hot Dog won’t move.
- Hot Dog won’t budge.
- Hot Dog doesn’t like the steamy sidewalks.
- Hot Dog doesn’t like being too hot.
- Hot Dog doesn’t like being too close.
or however the child chooses to describe the scene.
After the read-aloud, review the story to work on any of the skills previously presented and continue supporting literate language discourse.
Sequencing events
Ask children to relate some of the events of the story in sequential order. Go back over the illustrations for support as needed. For example –
- What happened after the little dog got fed up with the heat in the city?
- What made the dog feel so exasperated?
Then describe the kinds of adventures the little dog had at the beach. Use the wordless pages that show a sequence of events that are so ideal for describing. Your book talk may go something like this:
Q: How can you tell the dog was happy there?
A: First, he ran down the beach on the sand. Then he ran in and out of the waves. Then he shook off the water onto the sand. Next, he dug a hole in the sand. Then be found a rock and ran off with it.
Executive Functioning Skills
Organizing and planning events are essential components of executive functioning skills. Often children who struggle with these skills overlook the necessary steps and sequences involved for putting actions into place.
The story offers an ideal opportunity to outline the steps the dog’s owner took to get them to the breezy shores of a beach town. You might start out asking –
- How did the lady take her little dog from a hot, city street to the cool shores of a beach?
- What steps did she have to take to get them to their destination?
- How did she plan her spur-of-the-moment idea to go to the beach?
The pictures tell us how. They also leave plenty to fill in for an outline for her plan. Some steps to discuss include –
- Get into a taxi for a ride to their destination.
- Tell the driver to let them out at the train station.
- Go inside and purchase a ticket to their seaside destination.
- Check the time on the ticket for the departure of the train.
- Catch the train and board – just in time!
- (What might have happened if they hadn’t checked the time on the ticket?)
- Travel by train to their next destination.
- Board a ferry to cross the water.
- Disembark to arrive at the island town.
- Walk along the street past the stores.
- Take the trail to the beach.
- Set up a towel and umbrella on the sandy shore.
- Unleash the dog so it can run free and play.
Later in the book, you also may want to go through the steps and sequences they took to arrive home later that evening.
More Grammar and syntax
Going back over the illustrations to tell what happened is a good way to support the use of past tense syntactic structures, including regular and irregular tenses, such as –
- The fire truck was parked at the side of the street.
- The drivers drove down the street and honked.
- The dog barked at the skateboarder.
- The pigeons flew down to the sidewalk.
- The lady bought pretzels at the stand.
and so on.
Problem solving
As you review what transpired, ask children to state the problem in the story. Being able to identify and state the problem is one of the key elements to storytelling.
- Why was the dog so unhappy?
- What was so bothersome to the little dog?
- What were the conditions that caused the little dog to lay down in the crosswalk and not go any further?
Then ask how the problem was resolved.
- Did the lady understand how the dog felt?
- Did she want to do something to help the little dog?
- How did she solve the problem?
- How did the characters feel after the decision to go to the beach?
Verbal Expression, Cause-and-effect relationships
Encourage descriptions of the scenes in the city as you review the pages. Look for signs of how people feel and what contributes to their feelings. Ask –
- What’s causing them to look so frazzled?
Describe the scene where the lady pulls on the dog’s leash in the crosswalk.
- What caused the little dog to resist her?
- What do the characters’ expressions tell us about how they each feel?
Turn the page to see the characters looking at each other.
- How are the characters connecting? (eye contact)
- How are they letting each other know how they feel?
- Is the lady angry with the dog? How can you tell [she is not]?
- What does her expression imply?
- Does she understand how the dog feels? Why it’s behaving that way?
- What does the dog’s expression say about its feelings toward the owner?
- What might the little dog have said if it could have spoken in words?
Then, ask children whether it was a good idea to take the little dog to the beach.
- What does this tell you about the dog’s owner?
- What are her traits?
- What caused the lady to head over to the train station?
- How did her compassion help solve the problem?
Storytelling
This is an ideal picture book to support the development of storytelling skills. In reviewing the pages, discuss each story element as follows:
The beginning element involves the setting. Ask questions such as –
- Where does the story take place?
- Who is the story about?
- Does it begin in the daytime or nighttime?
- What is the weather like?
Now show how to put the first element together in storytelling discourse. It might go something like this –
One day inside an apartment, a little dog stands in front of the window to look outside. There is an air conditioner in the window. It is a hot day. As the little dog looks down at the city street, there is a lot of activity, and it is noisy. The little dog watches it and waits for its owner to come home.
Then discuss the second element, the initiating event. Ask –
- What happens to start this story off?
Responses may go like this –
- The dog’s owner comes home and takes it for a walk.
- The city is busy with crowds, noise, and commotion.
- The little dog is hot, uncomfortable, and unhappy.
Support the child in putting the second element together in storytelling discourse.
Then move on to structure the third element, the characters’ responses to the problem. Ask –
- How did the little dog react to those experiences?
- How did its owner respond to her little hot dog who refused to budge?
The storytelling may go something like this –
In the middle of a busy intersection with honking cars and taxis and skateboarders, the little dog lays down in the road and refuses to budge. The lady understands why the dog is reacting this way. She gets down on the crosswalk to look the little dog in the eye. She acknowledges its distress. She encourages the little hot dog to come along with her.
When the child has related the characters’ internal responses in storytelling discourse, it’s time to talk about the plan to solve the problem, called the external attempts. Ask –
- What did the lady do about the problem of her little hot dog’s distress?
- What was her solution to help it feel better?
- How did she go about doing this?
Support the child in relating the solution to the problem in storytelling discourse. Then move on to the next element, telling the consequences of this plan. Ask –
- What happened as a result of her decision to take her dog to the beach?
- Was it a good decision?
- Recount all the fun things that little dog was able to do.
And finally, in the last element, the storyteller describes the outcome. Ask –
- How did the characters feel after they went to the beach for the day?
- Did their dispositions change? In what way?
- What new experiences did the characters have that demonstrated how they changed?
Be sure to point out the scenes where Hot Dog –
- sits in its owner’s lap on the train trip home and licks her face
- reunites with a skateboarder in a better disposition
- at bedtime, dreams of reencountering the sea lions!
- Was this a good outcome?
Support children’s storytelling by teaching these elements and putting them all together when sharing books with this type of narrative structure. Helping children develop storytelling discourse is an important skill for academic success.
Relating personal experiences
Help children link the events of the story to their everyday lives. This can also help children in a group setting relate to each other in meaningful ways.
- Can they relate to the little hot dog? What part of the story do they most relate to?
Ask questions that enable children to tell what they would do in a similar situation, such as –
- Does your family have a dog?
- If so, what does your dog like to do in the summer?
- Where does your dog love to go?
- Where do you like to take your dog?
For those children who don’t have a dog, but can imagine the experience of having one, ask –
- Where do you think a fun place would be to take a dog on a hot summer day?
- Why would that be fun for a little dog?
___________ # # ____________
Special Note: Find an outline of storytelling elements and methods to support children’s storytelling in the Suggestions for Book Talk section of the Catalog for Grades 1 through 5+ of Books Are for Talking, Too! (Fourth Ed).
- You’ll also find other popular picture books that cover this book’s topics of Dogs, Emotions and Feelings, Perspective-taking, Sea and Seashore, and Seasons in the Topic Explorations Index.
- See listings of easily available books ideal for targeting all the skills addressed here – and many others – in the extensive Skills Index.
- Find those book titles cross-referenced in three age-related Catalogs and discover book treatments similar to this one that can provide you with methods, word lists, activities, and loads of ideas!
~ All in one resource ~
Books Are for Talking, Too! (Fourth Edition)
~ Engaging children in the language of stories since 1990 ~
Available on Amazon:
Note: Find the Spanish version of this book, titled, Canícula, on
https://www.buscalibre.us/libro-canicula/9788426148957/p/62020899